"The evidence points towards a distinction between tutoring and teaching," writes Donald Clark. "AI is increasingly capable of explaining, questioning, diagnosing, providing feedback and adapting practice. These are central components of tutoring, and it can already perform many of them effectively. What humans often contribute is something different: motivation, supervision, social interaction, safeguarding, judgement and organisation." This points to a range off different approaches, and not a single approach where AI does everything, "not one model but several: teacher-supported AI tutoring, guide-supported tutoring and autonomous AI tutoring, depending on the learner, subject and context."
Today: Total: Donald Clark, Donald Clark Plan B, 2026/11/17 [Direct Link]Please select a newsletter and enter your email to subscribe.
Stephen Downes spent 25 years as an expert researcher at the National Research Council of Canada, specializing in new instructional media and personal learning technology. With degrees in Philosophy and a background in journalism and media, he is one of the originators of the first Massive Open Online Course, has published frequently about online and networked learning, and is the author of the widely read e-learning newsletter OLDaily. He is a popular keynote speaker and has presented at conferences around the world. [More]
Support OLDaily
OLDaily has been free and open to all readers since 2001. It is a valuable and widely-used resource for educators, researchers, and learners worldwide. Please consider a monthly contribution to sustain the time and resources required to publish it every day.
Here's what's in the latest edition of OLDaily
I don't use X/Twitter at all and so I can't judge for myself whether there's some sort of movement back to the platform. I hear some people (like Leo Laporte) say from time to time that you have to be there because that's where all the news and AI people are, but I think I'm managing to keep up just fine without it. Anyhow, Matt Crosslin discusses this putative 'flocking' back to X/Twitter through a sceptical eye. And it does make me wonder what filter people on the platform are seeing the world through. For example, as Crosslin notes, "Saying the entire world got rich is… pretty out of touch with reality." And when people say there's "no viable option" other than to return to X/Twitter, I have to ask, no viable option for what? It's as though people don't undertsand that the entire world is a community of communities, not just one community.
Today: Total: Matt Crosslin, EduGeek Journal, 2026/11/17 [Direct Link]In my recent school bus training there was an e-learning component and it was mandatory to have cameras on at all times (it's a transport ministry regulation in Ontario). The benefits were immediately obvious, as a person taking the course while driving could easily be spotted. But as Sarah Silverman writes, in most cases it is preferable to allow students their own choice in how to interact. Still. AI changes the game somewhat, and in this article she describes her tentative forays into requiring video participation. Now she's "pondering other ways in which a desire to nudge students away from AI can be compatible with choice or recognition of learner variability."
Today: Total: Sarah Silverman, 2026/11/17 [Direct Link]I think of what I do in OLDaily as journalism of a sort, and I often draw the analogy between education and journalism, which I think are really two sides of the same coin, so this article about evaluating journalism for utility is relevant to me. It recommends a five-step guide that asks: what is the job we're doing, what is the practical outcome of that job, what signals that the outcome is happening, what are the numbers that are tracked, and what do the numbers show and don't show? I got a lot of this sort of calculation in my old job at NRC, and I'm a bit sceptical, because it's so totally service-oriented, and there ar many reasons why I would do something irrespective of the services to others being offered. And these services, even, are different for different kinds of recipients. For example, I use OLDaily to track what I'm reading. It began, and still is, a tool for me. Other people might think it's useful to keep track of what I'm reading, but still others might want a more generic environmental scan without grounding it in a particular perspective. I suppose I could measure all of this, but it really matters that I do so only if I'm performing some sort of utilitarian calculation, balancing it against, say, opportunity cost of doing something different. But I don't wok that way.
Today: Total: Patrick Boehler, Madison Karas, RJI, 2026/11/17 [Direct Link]Six Canadian universities are among the dozens that have signed this charter. It asserts that university presses are valuable for a variety of reasons, and then lists seven commitments they support. The noteworthy commitment is to "keep human judgement at the center of AI in publishing." There's also some pushback against some governments and regimes in the commitment to "expand participation in knowledge, and make all our work equity first," though this is undermined a but by the commitment to "put quality and integrity first." I would have like to have seen something about open access and wide dissemination, but that seems to have been overlooked. Instead we get "services and trade-offs behind different publishing models." Via Karen Keiller.
Today: Total: Name, Knowledge Commons, 2026/11/17 [Direct Link]This is an interesting article looking at the implications of merging artificial intelligence (AI) with social media (SM) to form AISM. "AI already shapes what we see on social media, it is starting to take over some of social media's role in filtering information, and it draws on social media content (which is very uneven in quality) for training." Obviously this is a problem, as it stands more and more as an intermediary between each of us with others as we try to form the connections that create a society. "Neither mainstream AI nor social media are being built to support the rich social dynamics essential to humanity — the nuanced interplay between individuals and the dense network of communities and institutions that has co-evolved over millennia." Richard Reisman, in this long article, calls for a "whole of society" response. "We need a sociotechnical infrastructure that is broad-based, continuously evolving, open to diverse experimentation at a range of scales, extensible, resilient, and governed to serve each and all." I think there is a lot to dispute here in the margins, but the main argument is mostly sound.
Today: Total: noreply@blogger.com (Richard Reisman - Sociotechnical network/systems thinker, visionary, inventor, pioneer | Author: @TechPolicyPress, FairPay | Nonresident Senior Fellow, Foundation for American Innovation)Richard Reisman, Smartly Intertwingled, [Direct Link]Web - Today's OLDaily
OLDaily Email - Subscribe
Web - This Week's OLWeekly
OLWeekly Email - Subscribe
RSS - Individual Posts
RSS - Combined version
JSON - OLDaily
Podcast - OLDaily Audio
Websites
Stephen's Web and OLDaily
Half an Hour Blog
Leftish Blog
MOOC.ca
Stephen's Guide to the Logical Fallacies
gRSShopper
Let's Make Some Art Dammit
Email: stephen@downes.ca
Email: Stephen.Downes@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca
Skype: Downes
Professional
National Research Council Canada
Publications
Presentations
All My Articles
My eBooks
About Stephen Downes
About Stephen's Web
About OLDaily
Subscribe to Newsletters
gRSShopper
Privacy and Security Policy
Statistics
Archives
Courses
CCK 2008, 2009, 2011, 2012
PLENK 2010
Change 11 - 2011
Education Futures - 2012
Learning Analytics - 2012
REL 2014
Personal Learning - 2015
Connectivism and Learning - 2016
E-Learning 3.0 MOOC - 2018
Ethics, Analytics - 2020
Mastodon
Mastodon OLDaily
Flickr Photos
Cosocial Pixelfed Amazon Wish List
Huffington Post Blog
Pocket Feed (RSS)
Pocket Feed (Tumblr)
CounterSocial
Services
Viewer
Backchannel
Ed Radio
gRSShopper Demo
Stephen Downes, Casselman, Canada
stephen@downes.ca
Last Updated: Nov 17, 2026 1:37 p.m.


