Academia.eduAcademia.edu
ACADEMIA Letters Online Education as a Discipline Steve McCarty, Osaka Jogakuin University Introduction This paper aims to concisely clarify how online education is an academic discipline, involving interdisciplinarity as well as disciplinarity. The author has been active in the online education field for over 25 years as an academic in Japan, with e-learning as both medium and object of investigation, culminating in the following perspectives. What a Discipline is Defining the terms “field” and “discipline,” which are not interchangeable, can help clarify what a discipline actually is. A field includes everything that can be studied in a wide area of related phenomena. A new field in particular like online education begins as virgin territory, then only certain areas of it are ever developed to some extent. An academic discipline forms around areas focused upon by research, grants, and specialized publications such as journals; regional or international academic or professional associations; and university departments with majors in the field. A growing canon of literature, to be cited where relevant, and specialized terminology also characterize a discipline. There can be auxiliary disciplines in related fields that lend methods or broader perspectives to a discipline, such that interdisciplinary collaboration in suitable areas of study advances overall knowledge. Many disciplinary issues arise among faculty members and other stakeholders of an academic institution including graduates, amid constraints or various incentives from the surAcademia Letters, March 2021 ©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0 Corresponding Author: Steve McCarty, waoesteve@gmail.com Citation: McCarty, S. (2021). Online Education as a Discipline. Academia Letters, Article 434. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL434. 1 rounding society, such that other meanings of “discipline” enter the picture. University departments exist not only to educate undergraduate and graduate students in their major subjects, but also to promote research and academic collaboration, to conduct faculty development, to contribute expertise to the local or global community, and to steward all the professions in society by upholding academic standards and professional ethics. What Online Education is In the broadest sense, online education can be any truly educational activities, not just training in skills, conducted through the Internet, whether formal, informal or self-education. In a more specific disciplinary sense, online education means teaching and other academic activities of accredited educational institutions conducted wholly or partly through the Internet. Disciplinarity and Interdisciplinarity Online education is interdisciplinary by definition as an auxiliary discipline for most subject matter areas. Its disciplinarity lies in academic rigor, pedagogical practice, and professional development including IT (information technology) skills. Online education or e-learning more broadly is thus both disciplinary and interdisciplinary. Moreover, disciplinarity provides criteria for interdisciplinarity. Academics nowadays are flooded with offers such as to publish in journals, and one way to rule them out is when their scope is too broad, no discipline is specified, or they combine fields incongruously. Interdisciplinarity or international collaboration are not necessarily appropriate unless both sides are on the same page with respect to global academic standards and ethics. Online education and e-learning, by design or necessity, widen the repertoire of the practitioner beyond either subject matter content or technology use alone, because they are interdisciplinary forms of education and learning, where pedagogy is requisite and further research is always needed to advance the disciplines involved. Defining by Contextualizing Online education is often used interchangeably with distance education or e-learning, but each term has a distinct meaning in its historical and disciplinary context. Distance education simply means that the teacher and students are in different locations, and it has a history of Academia Letters, March 2021 ©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0 Corresponding Author: Steve McCarty, waoesteve@gmail.com Citation: McCarty, S. (2021). Online Education as a Discipline. Academia Letters, Article 434. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL434. 2 over a hundred years as correspondence education by post or radio in spacious countries such as Canada and Australia. e-Learning refers to any kind of digital learning, whether offline or online, face-to-face or at a distance. Online education is conducted through networked computers in an Intranet or through the global Internet, either continuously or at times during a course of study. The Internet can be used in class or anywhere, therefore online education is not the same as distance education. Online education includes hybrid learning, partly online and partly face-to-face (hereinafter f2f), and blended learning, using the Internet possibly during as well as between f2f classes. e-Learning can be offline where the Internet is inaccessible, or by downloading online digital recordings such as podcasts. e-Learning has the broadest meaning and, disciplinarily, is most often used as the umbrella term in the literature, because it includes online education. Especially in a developing field, terms used interchangeably or defined variously need to be placed in their disciplinary context in order to clarify which definitions of technical terms are most salient. Placing terms in historical and cultural contexts as well would provide definitions with fuller dimensionality. For such a method, see the first chapter in McCarty, Obari, & Sato (2017), a whole book preprint available online. A characteristic strand of Online Education History Although the history of online education technically goes back to the 1980s, the Web became worldwide in the mid-1990s when universities in many countries connected to the Internet. One historical and disciplinary lineage began in 1996 with the first large-scale, international, wholly online academic conference, the Teaching in the Community Colleges Online Conference. The Opening Keynote Address from Japan by the author at the 1998 TCC Online Conference specifically proposed turning online education into a professional discipline, and forming the World Association for Online Education (WAOE) for year-round networking and sharing of knowledge. The discipline seemed to reach maturity in major universities globally, through online classes, MOOCs [massive open online courses], and IT support, until the pandemic in 2020 suddenly turned online education into a nearly universal necessity. For more on the “History of e-Learning” and diagnostic “Levels of Involvement with ICT” [Information and Communication Technologies], see the charts in McCarty (2019b). Academia Letters, March 2021 ©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0 Corresponding Author: Steve McCarty, waoesteve@gmail.com Citation: McCarty, S. (2021). Online Education as a Discipline. Academia Letters, Article 434. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL434. 3 Emergency Remote Teaching The term “emergency remote teaching” (hereinafter ERT), the original source for which is Hodges et al. (2020), arose to non-judgmentally describe the circumstances of educators mostly unprepared to cope with the new necessity to teach online, relieving them of unrealistic expectations as to learning outcomes. ERT does contrast with professional online education that learners choose, such as at national open universities in British Commonwealth countries or Asia. There the challenge is to equal or exceed the learning outcomes of f2f instruction, through the affordances of online media. In any case, online education expertise is currently in great demand. An Intercultural Dialogue on Online Education The following interview excerpts reflect the institutional culture of Indian academia and prompt the author to respond to actual disciplinary concerns: Is the online educational sector ready to cater to the increasing needs during this pandemic? Online education should not be a sector of technical specialists separate from educators, but rather a pan-disciplinary set of meta-skills that educators develop on top of subject matter expertise … [T]eachers and learners all need to rely on ourselves in a new world of online inquiry and communication … Because online classes offer flexibility of time, place, and pace, there is a demand for them even when teachers and learners are near each other. (McCarty & Panhathodi, 2020, p. 4) What kind of online education policy best suits the post-pandemic world? [T]he closest we have to an adaptable model for post-pandemic education is blended learning. That is, many of the technological solutions employed in online classes for emergency remote teaching will carry over into enhancing face-to-face classes with a supplemental online dimension available anywhere at any time … the study skills to navigate information and communication technologies (ICT) are some of the same skills needed in the future workplace. ICT can serve as both subject matter and medium of instruction. (McCarty & Panhathodi, 2020, p. 5) How is this going to affect the teaching community? Academia Letters, March 2021 ©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0 Corresponding Author: Steve McCarty, waoesteve@gmail.com Citation: McCarty, S. (2021). Online Education as a Discipline. Academia Letters, Article 434. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL434. 4 Now that educators worldwide are forced into emergency remote teaching, it is no longer the duty or responsibility of someone else. Blended learning and lifelong online learning are here to stay, so it is up to each educator to develop the skills to make online education effective, whether we have the luxury of face-to-face classes or not. Remote communication and teaching cause a physical and psychological gap between students and teachers. Will this permanently redefine ‘teaching’? Remote communication is not a cause but an effect of physical separation, and it provides an avenue for solutions to the tyranny of distance. Rather than remote teaching causing a psychological gap, it should aim to fill the gap. (McCarty & Panhathodi, 2020, p. 6) Conclusion: Online Education as an Academic Discipline Online education has been shown to exemplify a new field that develops into a discipline with its distinct terminology and other disciplinary characteristics. Online education as an academic discipline is a pan-disciplinary set of meta-skills and knowledge beyond subject matter expertise, an auxiliary discipline now needed by educators and researchers in most fields worldwide. Social issues and educational solutions are both global in scope, as are the academic standards and ethics shared by the global community of scholars. Responsibilities of career academics thus include professional development, international collaboration, and sharing of knowledge and resources. Global faculty development (McCarty, 2019a) involves mentoring, with intercultural sensitivity, in specific academic practices, some knowledge and skills of which apply to global online education. Rapid technological advances call for not only constant study but also placing pedagogy and humanism in charge of our powerful tools. In a post-pandemic world, not only will our pedagogy (McCarty, 2020) be more blended (Kim, 2020), but also our lifestyle. References Hodges, C., Moore, S., Lockee, B., Trust, T., & Bond, A. (2020, March 27). The difference between emergency remote teaching and online learning. Educause Review. https://er. educause.edu/articles/2020/3/the-difference-between-emergency-remote-teaching-and-onlinelearning Academia Letters, March 2021 ©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0 Corresponding Author: Steve McCarty, waoesteve@gmail.com Citation: McCarty, S. (2021). Online Education as a Discipline. Academia Letters, Article 434. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL434. 5 Kim, J. (2020, April 1). Teaching and learning after COVID-19. Inside Higher Ed. https:// www.insidehighered.com/digital-learning/blogs/learning-innovation/teaching-and-learningafter-covid-19 McCarty, S., & Panhathodi, R. (2020). How Asian universities can rise to the current challenge – Interview with World Association for Online Education President Steve McCarty in Japan. Education India Journal, 9(2), 3-8. https://www.academia.edu/43740683/How_Asian_Universities_can_ McCarty, S., Obari, H., & Sato, T. (2017). Implementing mobile language learning technologies in Japan. Springer. https://www.academia.edu/37986336/Implementing_Mobile_Language_Learning_Techn McCarty, S. (2019a). Meeting global faculty development needs in Japan. Child Research Net. https://www.academia.edu/38264974/Meeting_Global_Faculty_Development_Needs_in_Japan McCarty, S. (2020, May 24). Post-pandemic pedagogy. Journal of Online Education (New York University). https://www.academia.edu/43227493/Post_Pandemic_Pedagogy McCarty, S. (2019b). Thailand e-learning and mobile language learning workshop report. Asian Journal of Distance Education, 14(1), 158-161. https://www.academia.edu/40066421/ Thailand_e_Learning_and_Mobile_Language_Learning_Workshop_Report Academia Letters, March 2021 ©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0 Corresponding Author: Steve McCarty, waoesteve@gmail.com Citation: McCarty, S. (2021). Online Education as a Discipline. Academia Letters, Article 434. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL434. 6